A Practical Guide to Museum Ethics by Yerkovich Sally;
Author:Yerkovich, Sally;
Language: eng
Format: epub
Publisher: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers
Chapter 9
Restitution, Repatriation, or Retention? The Ethics of Cultural Heritage
Museum collections hold a multitude of different kinds of objects, ranging from those that embody diverse cultures from the ancient past to artistic creations of more recent years. Recently, however, a museumâs ownership of items within its collections has been challenged. Other countries, sovereign nations such as Native American tribes, and individuals whose families lost art and/or cultural objects during World War II have made claims upon works in museum collections that cause museums to consider whether they should return the objects in question or retain them in their collections. In some cases, the claims that have been made are based upon rights established by law. In other cases, decisions about the return or the retention of an object involve ethical considerations. This chapter will consider a range of situations in which museums face ethical dilemmas regarding cultural heritage.
As we have seen, a significant part of a museumâs responsibility in the process of acquiring objects for its collections is to ensure that the museum has clear title. Thus, when a museum acquires an object it should know the history of its ownership. While some owners and art dealers acting on their own behalf or on behalf of owners can provide a complete history, others have more limited knowledge. In the latter situation a museum is obliged to conduct due diligenceâto research the objectâs ownership history to ensure that acquisition would give the museum a clear and unencumbered title. Due diligence can involve extensive research that reveals an objectâs provenience and/or its provenance.
Provenience is a term used by archaeologists to refer to the place from which an artifact is excavated. But provenience, also referred to as the findspot, implies not just a location but also the artifactâs context, its relationship to the other things with which it is found or to the archaeological features in which it is found. Knowledge of an artifactâs provenience is critical to an archaeologistâs understanding of the piece and the reconstruction of its history. Patty Gerstenblith explains the complexity of the archaeological heritage and the critical nature of context in interpreting an artifact:
The archaeological heritage consists of the fragile and non-renewable physical evidence of humankindâs origins and behavior. Only carefully preserved, original contexts can furnish the data upon which the reconstruction of our past depends. Once this context is lost, the inherent value, that is the historic, cultural and scientific information that informs us about the object, is irreparably injured.1
Gerstenblith continues:
It is particularly crucial that artifacts be excavated together and in association with architectural features, such as houses, industrial areas, and burials. Careful excavation allows the archaeologist to place a found object in its proper chronological sequence and context, in turn allowing the reconstruction of each of a siteâs time periods, the characteristics of society at those times, and the connections among objects found and sites located throughout the world. It also allows those studying past cultures to reconstruct the functions of such objects, to learn more
Download
This site does not store any files on its server. We only index and link to content provided by other sites. Please contact the content providers to delete copyright contents if any and email us, we'll remove relevant links or contents immediately.
Life 3.0: Being Human in the Age of Artificial Intelligence by Tegmark Max(5162)
The Sports Rules Book by Human Kinetics(4057)
The Age of Surveillance Capitalism by Shoshana Zuboff(3964)
ACT Math For Dummies by Zegarelli Mark(3837)
Blood, Sweat, and Pixels by Jason Schreier(3472)
Unlabel: Selling You Without Selling Out by Marc Ecko(3456)
Hidden Persuasion: 33 psychological influence techniques in advertising by Marc Andrews & Matthijs van Leeuwen & Rick van Baaren(3278)
Urban Outlaw by Magnus Walker(3227)
The Pixar Touch by David A. Price(3191)
Bad Pharma by Ben Goldacre(3074)
Project Animal Farm: An Accidental Journey into the Secret World of Farming and the Truth About Our Food by Sonia Faruqi(2994)
Brotopia by Emily Chang(2877)
Kitchen confidential by Anthony Bourdain(2790)
Slugfest by Reed Tucker(2780)
The Content Trap by Bharat Anand(2760)
The Airbnb Story by Leigh Gallagher(2671)
Coffee for One by KJ Fallon(2406)
Smuggler's Cove: Exotic Cocktails, Rum, and the Cult of Tiki by Martin Cate & Rebecca Cate(2329)
Beer is proof God loves us by Charles W. Bamforth(2238)
